Skip to content
NOWCAST Pittsburgh's Action News 4 at 11pm Sunday
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

Investigation: Judge behind wheel of car that hit 13-year-old girl

Police find no wrongdoing by judge

Investigation: Judge behind wheel of car that hit 13-year-old girl

Police find no wrongdoing by judge

SAYING TONIGHT? >> IS DISTRICT JUDGE SUE HAGGERTY AND SO FAR SHE’S NOT COMMENTING ON WHAT HAPPENED. JUDGE HAGGERTY IS BASED IN SAXONBURG, BUTLER COUNTY. POLICE SAY THE JUDGE WAS NOT AT FAULT IN THIS CASE AND SHE WAS NOT CITED. THEY SAY PAIGE LAUTEN WAS CROSSING ROUTE 228 TO GET TO THIS SHEETZ WHEN HAGGERTY HIT HER. IT WAS ABOUT 5:30 IN THE EVENING ON NOVEMBER 29 WHEN PAIGE LAUTEN AND SEVERAL FRIENDS LEFT MARS MIDDLE SCHOOL FOR THE SHEETZ ON THE OTHER SIDE OF ROUTE 228. WESTBOUND TRAFFIC WAS SLOWING TO A STOP BECAUSE OF A RED LIGHT. THAT IS WHEN PAIGE LAWTON AND ANOTHER YOUNG PERSON TRIED RUNNING ACROSS THE HIGHWAY TO GET TO THE STORE. APPARENTLY, THEY DID NOT SEE JUDGE SUE HAGGERTY WHO WAS DRIVING EASTBOUND. THE JUDGES LEXIS STRUCK PAGE AND THROWING HER BODY INTO THE AIR. >> THE POLICE REPORT SAYS HAGGERTY’S ESTIMATED SPEED WAS 35 MILES PER HOUR BELOW THE SPEED LIMIT. THE REPORT ALSO SAYS POLICE DID NOT SUSPECT HAGGERTY OF ANY DRUG OR ALCOHOL USE AND THEY DID NOT ORDER HER TO BE TESTED. BUTLER COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY RICHARD GOLDINGER TELLS ACTION NEWS INVESTIGATES THAT HAGGERTY VOLUNTARILY SUBMITTED TO A FIELD SOBRIETY TEST AND THERE WAS NO INDICATION SHE WAS IMPAIRED. ACTION NEWS INVESTIGATES REQUESTED AN ON-CAMERA INTERVIEW WITH GOLDINGER BUT HE TURNED US DOWN. HAGGERTY, WHO’S BEEN A MAGISTRATE JUDGE FOR 25 YEARS, DID NOT RESPOND TO MULTIPLE REQUESTS FOR COMMENT. ADAMS TOWNSHIP POLICE SAY HAGGERTY DID NOT RECEIVE ANY SPECIAL TREATMENT. ASSISTANT CHIEF ROBERT SCANLON TELLS ME JUST BECAUSE A JUDGE WAS INVOLVED AND THEY’RE AN ELECTED OFFICIAL, THAT DOESN’T CHANGE THEIR STATUS. THERE’S NO FAVORITISM INVOLVED. A FACEBOOK PAGE MONITORING PAIGE’S RECOVERY SAYS SHE WAS IN THE CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL ICU FOR NEARLY A MONTH. SINCE THEN SHE HAS BEEN UNDERGOING REHAB AT THE CHILDREN’S HOME AND LEMIEUX FAMILY CENTER. PAIGE’S FAMILY DECLINED TO COMMENT. >> THERE IS NO CROSSWALK BETWEEN THE MIDDLE SCHOOL AND THE SHEETZ. FOLLOWING THE ACCIDENT, MARS AREA SCHOOL OFFICIALS MET WITH PENNDOT TO DISCUSS IMPROVEMENTS TO THIS INTERSECTION
Advertisement
Investigation: Judge behind wheel of car that hit 13-year-old girl

Police find no wrongdoing by judge

Nearly two months after a Mars Area Middle School student was struck by a car outside the school, she continues to recover at a rehab facility.Action News Investigates has learned a magistrate judge was driving the car that hit 13-year-old Paige Lauten.District Judge Sue Haggerty, who is based in Saxonburg, has not commented on the incident.A police report found Haggerty was not at fault, and she was not cited. Police said it was about 5:30 p.m. on Nov. 29 when Paige and several friends left Mars Middle School for the Sheetz on the other side of Route 228.When westbound traffic slowed to a stop, police said Paige and another young person tried running across the street. Haggerty was driving eastbound. Her Lexus struck Paige, throwing her body into the air.The police report said Haggerty's estimated speed was 35 miles per hour, which is below the speed limit.The report also said police did not suspect Haggerty of any drug or alcohol use, and they did not order her to be tested.Butler County District Attorney Richard Goldinger told Action News Investigates that Haggerty voluntarily submitted to a field sobriety test, and there was no indication she was impaired. Haggerty, who's been a magistrate judge for 25 years, did not respond to multiple requests for comment.Adams Township police said Haggerty did not receive any special treatment."Just because a judge was involved and they're an elected official, that doesn't change their status. There's no favoritism involved," said Assistant Chief Robert Scanlon.A Facebook page monitoring Paige's recovery said she was in the Children's Hospital intensive care unit for nearly a month.Since then, she has been undergoing rehab at the Children's Home and Lemieux Family Center.Paige's family declined to comment.There is no crosswalk between the middle school and the Sheetz. Following the accident, Mars Area school officials met with PennDOT to discuss improvements to the intersection.

Nearly two months after a Mars Area Middle School student was struck by a car outside the school, she continues to recover at a rehab facility.

Action News Investigates has learned a magistrate judge was driving the car that hit 13-year-old Paige Lauten.

Advertisement

District Judge Sue Haggerty, who is based in Saxonburg, has not commented on the incident.

A police report found Haggerty was not at fault, and she was not cited.

Police said it was about 5:30 p.m. on Nov. 29 when Paige and several friends left Mars Middle School for the Sheetz on the other side of Route 228.

When westbound traffic slowed to a stop, police said Paige and another young person tried running across the street. Haggerty was driving eastbound. Her Lexus struck Paige, throwing her body into the air.

The police report said Haggerty's estimated speed was 35 miles per hour, which is below the speed limit.

The report also said police did not suspect Haggerty of any drug or alcohol use, and they did not order her to be tested.

Butler County District Attorney Richard Goldinger told Action News Investigates that Haggerty voluntarily submitted to a field sobriety test, and there was no indication she was impaired. Haggerty, who's been a magistrate judge for 25 years, did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

Adams Township police said Haggerty did not receive any special treatment.

"Just because a judge was involved and they're an elected official, that doesn't change their status. There's no favoritism involved," said Assistant Chief Robert Scanlon.

A Facebook page monitoring Paige's recovery said she was in the Children's Hospital intensive care unit for nearly a month.

Since then, she has been undergoing rehab at the Children's Home and Lemieux Family Center.

Paige's family declined to comment.

There is no crosswalk between the middle school and the Sheetz. Following the accident, Mars Area school officials met with PennDOT to discuss improvements to the intersection.